Wanted: 2 Million Teachers
Question: What professional field will advertise 2 million new
job openings by 2010?
Answer: Teaching in America's schools.
Whether you're a student choosing a major or a corporate manager
considering a life change, the nation's educational leaders want you
to consider a teaching career.
But as you explore this career path, you must face a difficult
issue: Are you willing and able to accept the limited compensation
this field will offer for the foreseeable future?
The Labor Market
Chronic and severe teacher shortages are prevalent in America's
school systems; just witness the armies of teachers who've been
pressed into service with incomplete, emergency or out-of-field
certifications. And teacher supply will continue to lag demand,
largely due to the tidal wave of retirements among the predominantly
middle-aged workforce.
"Retirement is taking a lot of people out of the supply of
teachers," says B.J. Bryant, executive director of the
American
Association for Employment in Education Inc., a group based in
Columbus, Ohio. About 375,000 public school teachers will retire
between 1999 and 2009, according to the
National Center for Education
Statistics (NCES) in Washington, DC.
Another factor is increased student enrollment in the nation's
primary and secondary schools. Total enrollment in public and
private schools will grow from 52.2 million in 1997 to 54.3 million
in 2007, says the NCES.
Demand is also increased by policies such as
California's class-size
reductions; second-grade math can tell you fewer students per
classroom equals more teachers per school.
Geography
The US needs new teachers in a big way, but demand is distributed
unevenly, in complex patterns across the country.
Regionally, while primary and secondary enrollment is expected to
rise by 8 percent in the West from 1999 to 2011, the South will see
a meager 1 percent rise, and the Northeast will see a 4 percent
decline, according to NCES. These enrollment fluctuations are bound
to affect regional demand for teachers.
On a smaller geographic scale, there are substantial divergences
in projected enrollments, sometimes even among neighboring states.
For example, while enrollment in Virginia should increase 1.4
percent from 2002 to 2007, West Virginia's student population is
expected to drop by 2 percent during the same period, says an NCES
state-by-state
study.
Where are the new educators going? "Most people coming out of
teachers colleges don't want to teach in urban areas," says Roy
Einreinhofer, executive director of the
National Association of State
Directors of Teacher Education and Certification in Mashpee,
Massachusetts. "Everyone wants to teach in well-to-do suburban
neighborhoods," Einreinhofer says.
In addition, "the rural districts are really hurting, especially
in areas like special education," says Janice Jones, a high school
director of personnel in Evanston, Illinois.
Pay
The difficulty of providing competitive compensation is one
reason leading educators worry the teacher supply will continue to
fall short of demand.
While most other professionals improved their standard of living
during the roaring '90s, teacher pay was nearly stagnant. After
adjusting for inflation, the average city teacher's salary rose by
just $250 for the entire decade, according to the
American Federation of Teachers
(AFT), a union based in Washington, DC.
Teachers in big cities tend to earn more than their counterparts
in smaller communities. In 1999, new teachers with a bachelor's
degree earned a minimum of $37,045 in the New York City borough of
Yonkers; in Lincoln, Nebraska, the same group earned a minimum of
$20,883, says the AFT.
Starting teachers in Evanston currently earn about $40,000, says
Jones. "It's a very good salary, but you've got to look at where
you're going to live," she adds. In the East, for example, although
Boston teachers with a master's degree earn a maximum that places
them 15th among their colleagues in the top 100 US cities, that rank
drops to 81 when cost of living is considered.
Due to the 2001 recession and tax revenue shortfalls, many states
and municipalities aren't inclined to provide the magnitude of
salary increase that would begin to make teachers' pay more
competitive. And slack demand for 2002 college graduates is denying
newly minted teachers the leverage to negotiate a better wage.